What Really Happened at the Suez Canal?

Practical Engineering

1,8 млн көрүүлөр207

    Exploring the engineering principles behind the recent obstruction of the Suez Canal, which caused a weeklong disruption in global shipping traffic. I give a brief overview of the bank effect and dilatancy of coarse-grained soils. Hopefully, the video helps you understand a few of the engineering challenges associated with navigating massive ships through tiny canals and what can happen when they run aground!
    Errata:
    - I incorrectly described the landform as the "Suez Peninsula." It is the "Suez Isthmus."
    Practical Engineering is a KGup channel about infrastructure and the human-made world around us. Hosted, written, and produced by Grady Hillhouse. We have new videos posted regularly, so please subscribe for updates. If you enjoyed the video, hit that ‘like’ button, give us a comment, or watch another of our videos!
    CONNECT WITH ME
    ____________________________________
    Website: practical.engineering
    Twitter: HillhouseGrady
    Instagram: practicalengineering
    Reddit: www.reddit.com/r/PracticalEngineering
    Facebook: PracticalEngineerGrady​
    Patreon: patreon.com/PracticalEngineering
    SPONSORSHIP INQUIRIES
    ____________________________________
    Please email my agent at practicalengineering@standard.tv
    DISCLAIMER
    ____________________________________
    This is not engineering advice. Everything here is for informational and entertainment purposes only. Contact an engineer licensed to practice in your area if you need professional advice or services. All non-licensed clips used for fair use commentary, criticism, and educational purposes.
    SPECIAL THANKS
    ____________________________________
    This video is sponsored by [sponsor].
    Stock video and imagery provided by Getty Images, Shutterstock, Pond5, and Videoblocks.
    Satellite images copyright Maxar Technologies and CNES (Airbus)
    Tonic and Energy by Elexive is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License
    Source: kgup.info/get/hm2ac4XFp2-sbos/video
    Producer/Host: Grady Hillhouse
    Assistant Producer: Wesley Crump

    күнү жарыяланды 17 күн мурун

    Жорумдар

    1. Practical Engineering

      🌊 Enjoy videos with hydraulic demonstrations? Check out the playlist for more! kgup.info/channel/PLTZM4MrZKfW_XJht-K7a9_egIsFqze0nQ.html 🐥 Want to keep up with my other projects? Follow me on Twitter: twitter.com/HillhouseGrady

      1. Lucas Janse van Vuuren

        Here is a great example of what a big ship does when there is little water around it: kgup.info/get/ommDgoSieKhinY8/video

      2. Sebastian Falk

        I don't think it 's true that the squatting effect applies when passing under the Great Belt Bridge. I have heard this story before and passed under said bridge a couple of times with 19k TEU ships (400x60m). Every captain I've asked about this matter believes that it is not true. This makes sense, seeing as the depth is roughly 60m, which would make the depth under keel more than 40m with draught at 17m. If you have any sources to the story, I'd love to read them! Great content. Having passed through Suez just a couple of days after it was freed, and being a marine engineer, this was a very interesting video.

      3. Louis Strapp

        @Michael Onines nikki

      4. Jocko Harpo

        I Think it was because the steering wheel was intentionall turned too far to the right.

      5. Tony Hurd

        z youtube

    2. FireguyNtx

      Love the crane model, have been looking forever trying to find one. Where did you get yours? Also, great video's keep up the good work.

    3. vijay shetty

      Thankyou

    4. vijay shetty

      Squatting

    5. vijay shetty

      Reverses the water

    6. vijay shetty

      Bloch China using the channel save Australia

    7. vijay shetty

      It needs tug boats

    8. Tailgunner 69

      What really happened was a major socio political move by the DS...and why did he draw a male genitalia in his route plan before getting 'stuck...

    9. Karl FLORIAN

      Did you see the AIS-video: i would suggest, there was no "suction" - only a steering fault kgup.info/get/c5B7dKHEmGuhaqE/video

    10. Ken Engström

      Just imagine how hard ships will get stuck here: kgup.info/get/hJ2qYWK4ia-Og6E/video

    11. agnelo pereira

      Any one on board ships know that without power being lost, steering control electronics failure can give little time in a narrow space.

    12. Artur

      Same effect in aircraft wings. Lift is not mainly created below wings but on top of wing by greater wind speed compared to below wing. It's not intuitive and thats why flat wing needs large attack angle to create difference between top and bottom of wing

    13. Billy Williams

      They need a second lane.

    14. Phil Spaces

      I would really like to have a one on one nerd out session with you... well it would probably go smthin like this: me ask one question, then listen to you talk for hours

    15. ashzole

      1:05 greatest map of the flat earf!!!! the boat was intentionally setup to cause a blockage. it’s so obvious, look at the stocks of all the companies who had products on that boat plus the ones waiting. find which companies are being shorted, that’s you main clue

    16. Clickmaster5k

      As always I learned something new and interesting about something that seemed so everyday common place and simple.

    17. Platform2020

      Evergreen, Gates, chemicals, 5G Death

    18. Sigal Smadar

      I hope Israel is taking lessons on how to improve on this "little ditch" for their canal from Aqaba to Med. Should be fantastic!

    19. Syrian Hawk

      Evergreennd passed the Souez canal again and again !!! IT never get stuck

    20. Christian Prepper

      4:39 *FAILS ANSWER TITLE QUESTION* *Otherwise he does a fine job explaining the Canal's process, etc.*

    21. Concerned CitiZen Garden

      The entire event was orchestrated and manufactured to stifle global trade. This isn't conjecture. It's a fact.

      1. Garfie489

        Facts and conjectures getting easily confused nowadays it seems

    22. KENNETH STENSRUD

      You for real? This was a planned event..... Wake up people.

    23. PINOY BIZTALK VLOGS

      Awesome Video, thanks a lot

    24. Pacaj Albert

      Mali chlapec v knihe som videl púšť hneď som videl vodu ovocie zelenú púšť farba sa zmenila otvoril som atlas v škole videl som obraz rozšíriť pevninu nad oceánom ľahšie na zemi než na Marse

    25. Broc Luno

      I'm in the camp of big gust of wind pushed the ship to leeward and there was not enough room to swing the stern to push it back into the center. As they tried the bank effect took more toll on the volume of water on the leeward side. All the bow thrusters in the world were not going to keep it off the bank ... Imagine the forces on the Ever Given of just 20 kts of wind and all that sail area ...

    26. Beti RyanMercer

      Even I understood what you were saying. I almost failed geometry in H.S.

    27. Zhao Liang

      I am so curious what else he has just sitting around his garage like that flume.

    28. Narcissistectomy

      The inability to overcome pull-out force is the primary reason I’m now a father of three.

      1. RAY pitts

        also called gravity

    29. Daniel Warnes

      Excellent job of presentation to a general audience. Thanks

    30. kolim jone

      As a member of the Geotechnical fraternity, I must say this was an enjoyable presentation.

    31. Cechieri

      Nice! Thanks for explaining the physics/forces applied in the business on daily basis and in the incident. Cheers

      1. Cechieri

        @kolim jone I am not sure if the question was supposed to be directed to me but EVERGIVEN is the name of the ship and EVERGREEN is the name of the shipping company it is part of. One of the biggest container ships in the world BTW. Cheers

      2. kolim jone

        Why is Evergreen pronounced ever given?

    32. Daniel Saunders

      Strap a jet drive on the bulbous in a giant inflatable water wing that can keep you in the lane for the crossing in strong winds.

    33. Jim Armstrong

      trump stopped the nuke thats the story

      1. Garfie489

        @Jim Armstrong Be the first time Trump would have been involved in the truth for a long time if thats the case xD

      2. Jim Armstrong

        @Garfie489 the truth is coming

      3. Garfie489

        Given both Trump being totally uninvolved, and there being no Nuke - its certainly a story, but more in the fiction section of the library

    34. Kevin Mashilane

      You must demonstrate how the bank effect works💪

      1. RAY pitts

        same as down force only this goes side ways.

    35. Syed Akbar

      Well, the answer is simple and practical: widen and deepen ... Egypt should widen it to accommodate two way traffic and deepen it to accommodate a draught of 35 metres ...that shall accommodate the largest of the large vessels. It shall also double the traffic with substantial earnings ...

    36. Tridecalogism

      Francesco Schettino and Jacob Rusli Bin were piloting, I bet.

    37. Norman Harebottle

      Great discussion!

    38. Reece Flexner

      You are the best

    39. Professor Kitchen

      What I got from this video: Be careful where you put your bulbous appendage. The last thing you want is to have to dig it out with the whole world watching.

    40. davida1hiwaaynet

      I feel so sorry for the captain and engineering crew on this ship!

    41. Old Stud Buck

      Very interesting

    42. MrTench8

      What do you think of this explanation for the ship being wedged across the canal? kgup.info/get/aZFllnvTd21rloM/video

      1. MrTench8

        @Garfie489 Go ahead and disprove it then. I have checked out the meetings with the Turkish Government, they did take place.

      2. Garfie489

        Basically a load of easily disproven or improbable conspiracy theories.

    43. Brian Ligat

      Another great video Grady. Tell me, is the wife ever allowed in the garage? 2:34 3-day blockage?- yep, I've had one of those once.

    44. Michael Fjetland

      Excellent

    45. Sean Thompson

      so this is absoulte proof see the scene on this video with the swimming pool at sea, its absolutely crazy, if we were on a spinning ball it would be chaos down here but yet our seas are super calm unless there is a storm of course, think for yourself question everything the governments of the world are lying to us on a monumental scale the bigger the lie the more dumb people believe it just live the covid scam people actually believe its real??? think for yourself analyze and you see the truth in plain site, like an aeroplane its called and aeroPLANE because it flies over a FLAT PLANE not called an AEROPSHERE because its not a ball, the truth in PLANE site you only need to switch your brain on and ask the right questions and u can figure it!!

      1. Garfie489

        I love how people 2000 years ago could work out the earth is not flat, yet you seem incapable of doing yourself.

    46. Sean Thompson

      Tell me this you say the ships name is the EVERGIVEN when clearly on the side of the ship it says EVERGREEN??

      1. Garfie489

        Guessing you havent watched the video? Tell me, if you wear an Adidas shirt, is your name Adidas? - does your mum start calling you "Adidas" because you are wearing the shirt? Ships are giant billboards, thats why companies put their name on it

    47. Pamela Carnes

      Why is Evergreen pronounced ever given?

      1. Garfie489

        Because Ever Given is the name of the ship, as explained in the video

    48. rudy begonia

      test run to illustrate the effect of interupted prodoct deliveries

    49. Scott Gordon

      Going North around Russia? Methinks the polar icecap prevents that.

    50. petter derter

      could of just said it bottom out and moved the ship to the right or left but i get it ur thirsty for that add money or maybe ur excuse is well am into science i just wanted to make a fun cool video for my fans dont watch if you like to complain but then again you have ads turned on so it is about the money ever genius

    51. 556nutt

      More likely someone got paid off to cause it

    52. Ron Ellis

      Great explanation. Learned alot.

    53. The Builder

      clearly it was done to delay my packages

    54. Solid Rock

      Merci,, bonne démonstration scientifique repoussant la spéculation de malveillance de la part du pilote et du capitaine.

    55. James Riddlee

      Excellent video, so clear and easy to understand, thank you.

    56. vampire11

      Very good report.

    57. Marty Schwebel

      Gig'em Aggies!

    58. nieooj gotoy

      needs to be made to make the Suez canal even wider and deeper than it is right now.

      1. RAY pitts

        then boats/ships get built bigger same problem in panama bigger needs bigger.

    59. Pierre-Marc Rioux

      Niiiiice! Thanks! 😊

    60. olosnah1

      BS? it was deliberately put there.... it was NOT an accident. it was a blockade, not an obstruction.

      1. Dashcam & CCTV footage

        Exactly ))

      2. nieooj gotoy

        I'm expecting the canal pilot to be the problem. Suspect speed got too slow for adequate steerage.

    61. Shu Meister

      Strangely I didn't want to watch the news for this Suez canal issue. But you did such a nice thorough explanation, that I really enjoyed it! Thank you!

    62. Greg Mitchell

      Well explained as well as entertaining. subbed and voted uuuup

    63. Raman Shah

      My dear heart, that googly eyed toy boat labeled "EVERGREEN" wins cute on the Internet for the day

    64. Vona Laszlo

      very good video! and thanks for not over using the term 'maritime'.... it flooded all material related to this incident... 👍

    65. William Gregor

      Thank you that was both fun and educational. I was wondering.

    66. George si Cristiana Costea

      EVERGREEN OR EVER GIVEN, IT. IS COFUZING!?!

      1. Garfie489

        Its Ever Given, its literally explained in the video and is a very easy Google search - no confusion at all

    67. Kim Roscoe

      Another brilliant exposition that likely identifies the true causes of this accident.

    68. Hatem Afify

      A fantastic video thanks so much

    69. Dave Chapman

      a brilliant explanation, I'm now well informed, cheers for your great effort Sir, Best wishes NZ

    70. Saak Goyal

      perfectly explained. Thanks. Please Make a video, on how they did it.

    71. Donald Hetterscheid

      Hydrodynamics is an amazing science, affecting virtually anything that moves or uses pipes or tubes. Well explained here, this case actually had both internal and external forces in play.

    72. Th0rodin

      Looking forward to an engineers view on the bulbous bow. Though there is already a great video on it by Casual Navigation: kgup.info/get/Z32mdKrUdn5pZos/video

    73. can farts

      vibrate the sand to loosen it i think its called liquefaction

    74. psycronizer

      Oh..I thought the title was ...Sewer canal obstruction.....and I immediately thought of that time I was in a bar and this chick asked me to kindly push in her stool....being a gentleman I obliged...

    75. Art Smith

      I'm expecting the canal pilot to be the problem. Suspect speed got too slow for adequate steerage.

    76. Carlos Perdomo

      Great video and very well explained.

    77. Jaecht80

      This was an attack against globalists deep state

    78. Geoff Noyes

      Rumor has it that luckily another ship caught just behind was found to be carrying several containers of prunes on board. These were duly dumped overboard, the rest is history.

      1. oiuet souiu

        "This ability to resist pullout is a function of the pressure against the soil and the surface area of the anker" cats know

    79. Gary Weaver

      This prolly happens allot buuuut big media got wind of it and smelled money in the narrative. And that's all she wrote

      1. oiuet souiu

        I love it

    80. W. Nijssen

      Very good and detailed demo. For me very clear what has happened. Thanks.

    81. Carlos C

      Can you do a cooking episode?

    82. John.R C.

      Looking forward to that "Final Report" so the conspiracy theories and start in earnest.

    83. Colin Fletcher

      Did you see AIS before ,owned by Clinton and Walmart carrying lots of nafareous cargo,arms, human and weather control weapons. This was deliberate,US navy one side Russian navy outher,and still being held

    84. Eric

      So... What Really Happened at the Suez Canal?

    85. Brian Russell

      Thanks. You took some very complex engineering and geo-Techincal topics and presented it for the curious non-engineer like me to understand. Much appreciated.

    86. Merle Warnsholz

      Thanks for a simple explanation to a complex problem. Blessings to you sir.

    87. Ben Kennedy

      Has anyone questioned his soundproofing? 1st thing I noticed!

    88. Antolic Ivica

      Konačno nešto logično. Čestitam

    89. Arno Delanchy

      Even from France, your videos are appreciated and really amazing. Thank you for all the time you spent to make engineering clear enough to be understood by everyone. A.D.

    90. Tim B

      Yes, good. What is woder?

    91. Captain Phil

      I'm a Navigation Officer I have taken ships through the canal. My opinion is that without a mechanical failure, it was most likely a large gust of wind. Windage can effect the ship just as much or more than bank and squat effect. One minute of strong enough wind would be more than enough to change the ships rate of turn, enough to hit the side of the canal.

      1. Steven Czitronyi

        @Mike G Well, it's a question of probabilities. And by the way it wasn't just a "wind gust," but a major sand storm with speeds up to about 40 knots (46 mph). These happen only about once a year. And they have the greatest effect on the largest ships, and ships of the Ever Given size are at the moment only about 1 in 100 traversing the Suez Canal, and they don't necessarily traverse when there is a sand storm of that magnitude... There has been talk about whether or not to ban such ships from using the canal. Another option would be to stop all ship movement during sand storms, but because of lost revenue, it's doubtful they'd do that.

      2. Mike G

        If wind gusts are sufficient it is a wonder Ever Given events are not more frequent.

      3. Steven Czitronyi

        I am not a navigation officer, but I do have a knowledge of engineering and navigation, and I agree that the most likely cause of the accident was the wind. And more specifically, in all likelihood they would have tried to steer slightly into the wind in order to prevent the wind from pushing the ship towards the left bank (the wind coming from the east). So they would have tried to steer a few degrees east of the center-line of the canal. However, the exact number of degrees for this correction depends on the speed of the wind at any given time, and what seems to have happened was that the wind dropped somewhat when the accident occurred, and neither the captain nor the pilot noticed this, and they failed to correct the direction of the ship, with the result that the ship started approaching the right bank, and ended up digging in. After which, the inertia of the ship pushed the stern towards the left bank. So from the engineering and navigational points of view it's not really difficult to understand what happened.

      4. Captain Phil

        When we do use tugs usually we attach one forward and one aft.

      5. Captain Phil

        @evviper24 yes, some ships have a tug escort but not often. First tugs cost a lot of money to hire. Then the way the canal works is with convoys of ships, if each convoy (South and North) had 10 ships and each ship had two tug boats the convoys now total 60 vessels and would be too long to pass each other using the two lane system in the middle. Also the only way the convoy moves together is by speed matching, at about 8 knots. If you try to speed match a convoy of 30 vessels it wouldn't work, unless the tug boat mooring lines were very slack, in which case there might not be any point in attaching them. Also tug operations are usually very slow, less than 4 knots. At 8 knots it would be difficult for a tug boat to make any difference to the bow of the Ever Given because of the weight of the ship and the inertia of it moving forward.

    92. Lexx1976

      My 80 pound load of china-white-heroin was on this ship. My clients were pretty indignant about the delay.

    93. bmxican1023

      I love it

    94. oiuet souiu

      "This ability to resist pullout is a function of the pressure against the soil and the surface area of the anker" cats know

    95. Informative Floss

      Current timeline in Restoration of America Cabal capitulated last Wednesday, April 28th. Strange things happened at the White House beginning Wednesday night with ambulances at the front door, snipers on the roof, police with blacked out radios, and a citizen reporter arrested and disappeared. Today, May 1, 2021, the alliance will 'stage WW3" in order to put martial law in place world wide. Satellite communication system Starlink (Space Force has put up over 128 communication satellites for Starlink @t ) will take over and will wipe out 'Mockingbird' @t Starting today, May 1, 2021, several countries are going on 'lock down due to covid' for the 10 days of darkness which means a global shut down of MEDIA and the implementation of NESARA debt relief. Monday the 3rd of May, military will be on high alert. Tuesday the 4th of May, our new Republic is scheduled to begin. Thursday, the 6th of May, the Emergency Broadcast System (EBS) will begin issuing reports via Starlink. By May 6th, there will be Martial Law worldwide and implementation of the global currency reset. May 7, 2021, John F Kennedy, Jr will be confirmed as VP and his wife Caroline Bissette as the 2nd Lady. The 20th of May, Trump's EO enacting national emergency comes to an end. By Sunday, the 1st of August, declassification of everything will be completed. By the 8th of Aug, NESARA blockchain elections @t shall have reduced governments to 10%. August 8, 2021, Trump presidency and NESARA are to be activated. Trump will be officially recognized as our POTUS. So........starting today, May 1, 2021, we should see these things actually taking place. Dear God, I hope so. Restored Republic via a GCR: Special Report as of April 30, 2021. 14,498 views•Apr 30, 2021 @ And we have another current update. Sat, May 1, 2021. Restored Republic via a GCR: Special Report as of May 1, 2021 Some info repeat but some new, from previous update. Restored Republic via a GCR: Special Report as of May 1, 2021. @

      1. oiuet souiu

        "Evergiven" or "Evergreen"? Go play in traffic children, it is safer than listening to this rubbish!

    96. Angel White

      It was Israel and the USA Israel want thier own canel to take all the wealth out of eygipt

    97. Rick Standish

      Great vid, I just subscribed. Thank you.

    98. Oren C

      Excellent video. Thanks for sharing

    99. Moud Elzomor

      👍❤️More huge size ships passed safely before in egyptian canal.. It was obvious wasn't any oceans high waves.. It was basically unexperienced captain not any egyptian was driven the vessel.. Billion dollars was damage as 400 ships waiting for a week.. no need engineering details to be used for racist against nations... It is international law to hold the ship and the captain till payimg the damage... It is not hostage as USA holding 3000 muslims in Cuba did nothing for 20 years.. The world got sick of USA KILLING PEOPLE IN JAPAN, VIETNAM, CAMBODIA, KORIA, KONGO, LATIN AMERICA, SOMALIA, AFGHANSTAN, IRAQ, LEBONAN, LYBIA.. HOW MANY MILLIONS PEOPLE DEAD? to protect Isreal? There is god created all of us to live in peace...for sure there is deep hell for such killers and for those defending them... No more racist.. No more wars and hate❤️

    100. Tanner Animation

      ###""" Challenge """### Make a RC that doubles as a drone. Having Wheals that double as a Propellers. Rules: -RC must have 4 Wheals in land mode and must have 4 propellers in flight mode. -Propellers and Wheals must be one and the same. -Transformation Legs or landing Legs are allowed. -Transformation legs or landing legs can not have any additional Wheals or propellers. -Drone must be able to vertically take off with an initial velocity of 0.0. -Drone must be able to maintain stable flight and perform controlled manoeuvres. -After Drone has completed manoeuvres. Drone must be able to land in the same spot it took off from. -No parts can be added or subtracted before, during, or after transformation, between land and flight mode. If you have any questions feel free to ask. I look forward to seeing some new results.